Before his death William Penn had deeded a certain 5,000 acre tract of land to his daughter, Lady Letitia Penn-Aubrey. The property was titled "The Barony of the Rose." It was uninhabited by Europeans, but it did happen to be home to Captain John and his clan. Lady Letitia apparentlyintended to to erect a pseudo-aristocratic government on the parcel, complete with all of its peculiar tradition and ceremony. Her father specifically granted her, "the privilege of holding 'Court Baron'... for the conservation of the peace," and in 1731 her brothers relinquished any claim to the property in return for one red rose from their sister to be paid yearly on July 24.
It would have been difficult for Lady Letitia to hold court in Nazareth, though, because she lived in England. Instead, it was arranged that the famous itinerant Methodist preacher George Whitfield (who had become acquainted with the Moravians) would use the property to erect a school for black slaves who had escaped to the North. A group of Moravians whom Whitfield had encountered in Georgia, led by Peter Böhler, were commissioned to build the school on the property, but before it could be finished, a theological dispute arose between them and the Methodist brethren, and Whitfield kicked the Moravians out of the Barony, back to Bethlehem.
Shortly after the dispute, however, the Moravians arranged to purchase the tract from
Whitfield outright, whereupon the rights and privileges of Baroness of the Rose were transferred to Countess Erdmuth Dorothea von Zinzendorf und Pottendorf, the wife of the Moravians' magnanimous benefactor. Like Lady Letitia, however, the Countess lived in Europe, but she was represented in the Barony by her daughter, Benigna.
The Moravians completed the schoolhouse (today named Whitfield House) and renamed the property the Barony of Nazareth (a fitting counterpart to the nearby settlement at Bethlehem). As an artifact
of the Barony of the Rose, the local inn continued to be called Der Gasthof zur Rose, and today Rose Inn Ave. still runs near the center of town.
Instead of using the property as a haven for escaped slaves, however, the Moravians intended to erect an outpost for their Indian missions. It is ironic, though, that the Moravians began their missionary endeavor by acquiring land that fell within the controversial Walking Purchase. In fact, by purchasing the Barony, they were actually dispossessing Captain John and his clan. Captain John protested loudly to the Pennsylvania government and to the tribes of the other Five Nations. He received no support from either source (the other tribes were still angry that during the Walking Purchase affair about five years earlier, the Delawares had not consulted with them. They were now prepared to allow the Delawares to "lie in their bed as they had made it.")
This opened up the door for the Moravians' first preludes to the Delaware tribes: they had come to America to convert the Indians -- not to displace them. In a fashion reminiscent of William Penn's original treaty back in 1682, Count von Zinzendorf negotiated to purchase the property a second time -- this time from Captain John. The missionary John Heckewelder recorded that Zinzendorf, "paid them out of his private purse, the whole of the demand which they made in the height of their ill-temper, and moreover gave them permission to abide on the land, at their village, where they had a fine large peach orchard, as long as they should think proper."
Captain John does not appear to have taken the Moravians up on their offer to allow him to live indefinitely on the land at Nazareth without paying rent. But others from his tribe did, and gradually they began to participate actively in life at the Moravian missions. Zinzendorf's magnanimity and peaceful nature may have reminded them of William Penn's generosity and fairness a generation earlier. They were also sorely in need of the Moravians' help, partly because of especially hard winters during those years and partly (tragically) because of the diseases (especially smallpox) that were ravaging their population as a result of their interaction with Europeans.